Discussion of the Book for June 2011
Posted by bangkokbookclub on July 8, 2011
Troubles” by J.G. Farrell
A large portion of the group thought this was a tedious and overrated novel. Though the Majestic was a good metaphor for a crumbling and out dated British rule (around the globe), many members found the premise unbelievable and the characters overly drawn. Some were disappointed that the author did not take the opportunity to provide more information about this interesting period in Irish history, but agreed that Farrell’s decision to focus primarily on the attitude of the English towards the Irish was effective and gave a good sense of the social dynamics of the time.
Several thought it was very entertaining at times but far too long, ultimately a confusing and dissatisfying mixture of comedy and pathos. One member commented that he felt Farrell couldn’t decide whether he wanted to write a humorous or serious novel.
The next meeting will be on July 27th and the book is: “Arthur and George” by Julian Barnes.
Advertisement
